March 29th: von Fintel & Gillies 2021
We read Still going strong by Kai von Fintel and Anthony S. Gillies. Below you can find the original abstract from the paper.
PAPER: von Fintel & Gillies (2021). Still going strong. Nat Lang Semantics (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11050-020-09171-x
WHEN: Monday 29 March 2021, 15:00 - 16:30 (Amsterdam time)
ZOOM LINK: https://uva-live.zoom.us/j/87258902766
PDF: https://formal-semantics.github.io/download/Fintel-Gillies2021.pdf
DISCUSSION NOTES: https://formal-semantics.github.io/download/Fintel-Gillies2021_notes.pdf
ABSTRACT:
In “Must …stay …strong!” (von Fintel and Gillies 2010), we set out to slay a dragon, or rather what we called The Mantra: that epistemic must has a modal force weaker than expected from standard modal logic, that it doesn’t entail its prejacent, and that the best explanation for the evidential feel of must is a pragmatic explanation. We argued that all three sub-mantras are wrong and offered an explanation according to which must is strong, entailing, and the felt indirectness is the product of an evidential presupposition carried by epistemic modals. Mantras being what they are, it is no surprise that each of the sub-mantras have been given new defenses. Here we offer them new problems and update our picture, concluding that must is (still) strong.